Appraisals, Underwriters and the Third Rail of the Housing Recovery

Real Estate Agent with Realty Executives

In theory, an appraisal is an independent evaluation of a property by a neutral third party to determine its likely worth in the open market.

In practice, it has become the de facto final word on a property’s worth, overriding the agreement between a willing buyer and seller.

How is it that the guestimation of value has supplanted the actual sale as the ultimate arbiter of worth? That the tail has come to wag the dog? Thank your friendly financial institution.

You see, appraisals are rarely ordered for cash transactions. Why? Because the buyer has already reviewed the recent sales comparables and negotiated the best terms he/she could with the seller before arriving at the final sales price. Appraisals are requirements of (most) financed transactions because they are really not for the benefit of the buyer. They are an added layer of protection for the lender that is putting up the bulk of the purchase money.

Certainly an understandable requirement from an institution that is taking on the risk of lending money against a property that may or may not represent suitable collateral, depending on the drooling-idiocy factor of the buyer. The bank demands an appraisal to validate the purchase price before ponying up the cash; makes perfect sense.

Where things have gotten a bit off-kilter as of late is in the bank’s internal review process of the appraisal. Times were, the appraisal came back at value, and you were good to go. Your shrewd purchase was confirmed by a non-biased review by a licensed professional. After the housing meltdown, however, banks have taken to assigning the bulk of the blame for the whole fiasco to unscrupulous loan originators and appraisers for falsifying loan applications and willfully inflating values, respectively; ignoring their own ridiculous loan products that were offered to people who never should have been candidates for stated income, interest-only financing vehicles, they are determined to stamp out any potential for fraudulent dealings that exposes them to similar risk in the future.

Tightened appraisal standards came to pass, including restrictions placed upon direct selection of appraisers (most orders go to faceless appraisal management companies now, who in turn select the appraiser). Loan originators and Realtors have limited access to appraisers these days, lest we corrupt their sensibilities and bend them to our devious aims.

The appraiser is now free to perform his evaluation in an ivory tower, unencumbered by the incentive-laden hands that would pull at him to bring in a value reflective of the sales price.

Or is he?

While charges of fraud and artificial inflation of value have been heaped upon the working stiffs from up high, I posit that the exact opposite is now occurring.

With the current barriers in place, the banks themselves are the only ones with unfettered access to the appraiser during the course of a transaction. Beholden only to those banks, appraisers have been put in the impossible position of providing fair evaluations of properties for institutions that have a vested interest in suppressing value/risk.

Bluntly, banks are actively pressuring appraisers to devalue properties.

By using the veto power of the underwriter review, they may demand that an appraisal which came in at value be reworked to use different comps or adjustments made to the physical attributes of the house that they dispute (square footage adjustments, etc).  They may demand that adjustments (downgrades) be made for market trends, etc.

In short, some bean counter in an office in South Dakota is using his position to dictate the final version of the appraisal to the licensed professional who has actually physically viewed, measured, photographed and evaluated the property.

This is how appraisals initially come in at $400,000, only to get knocked down to $350,000 upon underwriter review. And when that happens? You get to appeal the appraisal … to the very institution responsible for the final disparity in value.

Akin to taking one’s death sentence appeal to the hangman himself.

Appraisers have little choice but to comply if they want to keep their accounts with the big banks in good standing. Further, until the underwriter signs off on the appraisal, it really doesn’t matter what value is reflected in it. He decides the house isn’t worth what you are paying for it, your loan is scuttled. Unless the seller agrees to sell the property to you at the reduced price (unlikely in a market that is now generating bidding wars) or you have additional cash to plunk down to make up the difference, you are out the cost of the appraisal, inspections and emotional investment in the property.

The big banks are artificially suppressing our values, and they are charging you $350-400 a pop to do it.

What’s the best way to ensure that you are working with an institution that is actually interested in helping you purchase the home of your dreams? Think local. Many small, local banks not only work with select appraisers who actually know the areas they cover (as opposed to trucking them in from Tuba City on the luck of the draw), but are more likely to keep your loan in their portfolio. One of the primary drivers of a big bank’s decision to take on your loan is how sellable it is on the secondary market. Any quirks with the property, such as it being recently “flipped” by an investor, and the loan becomes less attractive to them. Out come the knives.

Add the suppression of value and subsequent hindrance to the market’s recovery to the list of charges I wouldn’t mind seeing in a financial perp-walk. Such manipulation of the market and coercive impact on property values does not merely effect buyers, but it robs sellers at large of what little equity they may have left. Of course, I suppose it is only fitting that the very institutions that spawned the ponzi schemes that led to housing’s demise are the same that would stand in the way of its nascent resurrection.

Such practices are an affront to us all, and must be stopped.


Re-Bloggged 1 time:

Re-Blogged By Re-Blogged At
  1. Nancy Laswick 02/26/2012 03:25 PM
Spam prevention

Accessibility option: listen to a question and answer it!

To submit the form,
drag the folder to the circle on the side.

Type below the answer to what you hear. Numbers or words, lowercase:

Real Estate Market Trends
Arizona Maricopa County Scottsdale
Almost Anything Goes
Arizona Real Estate
Club Chaos
Dedicated Bloggers

Comments 16 New Comment

Paul Slaybaugh
Scottsdale, AZ Real Estate
Realty Executives
Hmm, after reading your disparaging remark on J Phillip's blog, I retract my retraction. You are some piece of work.
February 28, 2012 01:55 AM
Sharon Alters
Your Fleming Island Relocation Agents.
Coldwell Banker Vanguard Realty

Paul, just came over to see if you had written anything lately and oh, I so agree with you on this one. Not sure where some other people are coming from...

I have had appraisers tell me to my face that they do not give anything really for the overall condition, eg, upgrades of a house. That it's basically four walls. What???? And the fact that there is no formal review process to sppeal an appraisal. Not fair.

But finally I guess the banks think our values are low enough, as some changes went into affect recently where appraisers are given more latitude for condition and I even read a blog from one who adjusts for distressed sales. I have asked that question over and over to appraisers during the last 5 years and not one of them would admit to doing this. Not one. Hmmmm.

As always, excellent and congrats on your new baby daughter! Now Brandi has a little gal pal and you have a little pricess:)


March 04, 2012 12:18 PM
Paul Slaybaugh
Scottsdale, AZ Real Estate
Realty Executives

Hi Sharon,

I could write about puppies, and a certain demographic would take issue. Stick around any platform long enough and your bound to run afoul of a certain percentage.

Appraisers have a brutally difficult job in the best of circumstances, and their current captivity in the underwriter's ivory tower merely exascerbates that truth. My concerns with the present market has less to do with the competence of the appraisers, but the constant demands from underwriters for the professional arbiter of value to adjust reports to fit his/her untrained sensibilities. The banks don't want buyers, sellers and agents to influence the evaluations, and thus have lobbied for the tightened standards that limit contact, and yet they are allowed to essentially dictate the terms of the appraisal to the appraiser unchecked. It's a farce. Not only are buyers losing the homes they have their hearts set on despite an initial finding from an appraiser that the sale is at market value, but manipulated appraisals adversely impact sellers at large by stifling prices. 

Thanks for the congrats on my baby girl. We are one happy brood at present. :)

March 04, 2012 01:47 PM
Jason Sardi
Your Agent for Life
Auto & Home & Life Insurance throughout North Carolina

If it makes you feel any better, she isn't a fan of mine either.

Hope all is well, amigo.

May 24, 2012 01:21 PM
Eric Michael
Metro Detroit Real Estate Professional 734.564.1519
Remerica Integrity, Realtors®, Northville, MI

Wow. How did I miss this one? Totally agree, buddy. Do I have some lady who opened up her house watch my kid or someone who's licensed, tested, proven the house is safe, etc?

August 29, 2012 02:33 PM

Paul Slaybaugh

Scottsdale, AZ Real Estate
Ask me a question
Spam prevention

Accessibility option: listen to a question and answer it!

To submit the form,
drag the world to the circle on the side.

Type below the answer to what you hear. Numbers or words, lowercase:

Additional Information

See Scottsdale through the eyes of a native son!

Subscribe in a reader

Subscribe to Paul's Scottsdale AZ Real Estate Chronicles by Email

website stats

visitor stats